|
There was never any mystery in the limitations of
evolutionary theory. In general, severe, almost certainly fatal, mathematical
challenges have always stood in the way of selectionist assumptions. In a now
classic text, Evolution From Space, Hoyle and Wickramasinghe give
one version of this objection.
Darwinian
evolution is most unlikely to get even one polypeptide right, let alone the
thousands on which living cells depend for their survival. This situation is
well known to geneticists and yet nobody seems prepared to blow the whistle on
the theory.
This viewpoint has been ‘refuted’ so many times that we
forget genetic research has essentially confirmed it with the discovery of new
developmental structures and processes. The full random run is in fact
‘compressed’ by the existence of some other process of development. In general,
be wary of statistical reasoning applied to evolution. Even the suspicion of a
directional process will throw any calculations here out of kilter. The amount
of sophistry attempting to counter Hoyle, strewn over the Internet, is
remarkable.
|